Trading Books: ‘The Definitive Guide to Position Sizing’


Author: Van Tharp
Publisher: The International Institute of Trading Mastery

Book Review Rating:
**** Recommended

Topics Covered:

Click the image below to buy it now on Amazon:

Trading book review_definitive guide to position sizing_van tharp

Conclusion:

I recommend ‘The Definitive Guide To Position Sizing’ as a trading book for everyone who wants to know how to meet their objectives trading in the financial markets. Trading success is about far more than just entries and exits – Position Sizing is one of the key drivers of success and Van Tharp is an authority in this area. It is one of a few very outstanding trading books that any serious system trader should have read.

Overall this trading book is well worth reading – Van Tharp is a distinct authority in this area, there is no better source than this book or one of Van’s workshops to learn about position sizing and its importance.

Link to this book and other Van Tharp products

Transcription Of Video Review:

Hi, it’s Adrian from Trading System Life and today’s trading book review is about Van Tharp’s Definitive Guide to Position Sizing. Now Van Tharp is absolutely an authority in the area of position sizing. He’s probably written more on position sizing and using position sizing to meet your objectives in trading than pretty much any other author. He sets the scene right up front. On the cover of the book he says, size does matter in the market and it’s absolutely right. Position sizing is probably the single most important topic for any trader to get their head across if they want to be sustainable and if they want to meet their trading objectives.

This book promised to be a really fantastic resource and I absolutely wasn’t disappointed with it. What’s really great about the Definitive Guide to Position Sizing is that it’s exactly that. It’s a definitive guide. The book covers position sizing and that’s it. There’s no other guff, it doesn’t try to be all things to all people. It talks about a whole range of position sizing models, gives the advantages and the disadvantages of each one and it talks about how to use position sizing in order to meet the objectives that you’ve got for your trading.

The real trick is that you have to be absolutely clear on what your trading objectives are, so that you can then take the models that Van gives you and build them into your trading in a way that allows you to meet those objectives. If you’re not clear on exactly what it is you’re trying to achieve, then no amount of reading can help you. So as always, we start by writing our objectives, being crystal clear on what it is we want to achieve and what we want to avoid in the markets.

Then we take these models that are presented in the book and use them to adjust and customize the way you size each of your positions, how much you risk on each trade in order to really meet those objectives. Once you do that, trading becomes a really powerful mechanism because you’ve got a trading system that works, you’ve got your objectives clear and you’ve got a position sizing model that works with both the trading system and your personal objectives to give you exactly what you want in the markets. That’s just what we need.

The book does a really great job of explaining several different position sizing models that you can use and also a number of position sizing models that you really should avoid. Probably one thing which is missing for me, though, is some concrete tangible examples of how to take those models and build them into different types of trading systems. You can figure this stuff out for yourself, so it’s not the end of the world, but I just think that small addition probably would have taken the book to that next level where traders could really take action on the advice.

One insight that I did get from the book that which was really interesting came from a discussion about which position sizing models we should avoid as traders. Now what was really interesting for me was, several of them I had heard of but hadn’t seen a really good discussion of the down side, the real riskiness of those models anywhere else. When I read it, it was like light bulbs going off, because a couple of those models I had felt uncomfortable with when I read about them from other books, but couldn’t quite put my finger on why. Some of them were a little bit complicated, but they were coming from credible sources – from really famous traders, but they just didn’t sit well with me.

When I read this section of the book, it crystallized exactly what the problems were with those models and really gave me a good understanding of what makes a good position sizing model, which put me in a great position for when I went back to the other models which the book advocates, so I could choose the ones that best fit me, that also had the combination of advantages and disadvantages that I really wanted.
This book is absolutely best for people who have already come to the realization that trading successfully is about far more than just entering and exiting the market. There’s a lot more to it than just that and probably one of the most important topics is exactly what this book’s about, which is position sizing.
Position sizing is about how much you risk on each and every trade and how much risk over all you take to make sure that your portfolio and your trading systems can meet the objectives that you set out for yourself.

I gave this book four out of five. I fully recommend it. It is not going to give you everything about trading, it’s not an all-encompassing trading bible, but it does give you pretty much everything you need to know about position sizing, which is one of the most critical topics to get across.
I fully recommend it.

Finally, if you haven’t already, please click on the link below and download my free special report on my top ten lessons that I learned when I was reading 150 trading books. If you’re making any of the classic mistakes, doing any of the things that I did when I started, that special report alone could save you years of your learning curve and thousands and thousands of dollars. Have a read of the free report quickly before you do anything else.

Also, please leave me a comment below. If you have any questions about this video or anything else, ask me there and I’ll do my best to get back to you personally. In the meantime, bye for now.

Free Report:  The 10 Commandments For Profitable Trading From 150 trading books

 

Frequently Asked Questions about Guide to Position Sizing

What is position sizing in trading and why is it important?

Position sizing is a critical aspect of trading that determines how much of your capital you allocate to a particular trade. It’s all about managing risk and ensuring that no single trade can significantly impact your overall portfolio. Here’s why it’s important:

  • Risk Management: Position sizing helps control the amount of risk you take on each trade. By determining the size of your position based on your account equity and risk tolerance, you can limit potential losses to a level you’re comfortable with .
  • Consistency: Consistent position sizing allows you to treat all trades equally, which is crucial because you can’t predict which trades will be winners or losers. This consistency helps in maintaining a stable equity curve over time .
  • Objective Achievement: Proper position sizing aligns with your trading objectives. It ensures that your trading system works in harmony with your personal goals, allowing you to meet your financial targets effectively .
  • Psychological Comfort: Trading with an appropriate position size reduces stress and emotional decision-making. Knowing that you’re not overexposed in any single trade can help you stick to your trading plan without panic .

In essence, position sizing is about balancing risk and reward, ensuring that your trading strategy is sustainable and aligned with your financial goals. It’s one of the most critical components of a successful trading system .

How do you calculate the optimal position size for a trade?

Calculating the optimal position size for a trade is crucial for managing risk effectively. Here’s a straightforward approach:

  1. Determine Risk Per Trade: Decide what percentage of your total account equity you’re willing to risk on a single trade. A common choice is 1-2% of your account balance .
  2. Calculate Dollar Risk: Multiply your account equity by the percentage risk per trade to find the dollar amount you’re willing to risk. For example, if you have a $10,000 account and risk 1%, your dollar risk is $100 .
  3. Identify Risk Per Share: Determine the difference between your entry price and your stop-loss price. This is your risk per share .
  4. Calculate Position Size: Divide your dollar risk by the risk per share to find the number of shares to buy. For instance, if your dollar risk is $100 and your risk per share is $2, you would buy 50 shares .

This method ensures that your risk is consistent across trades, helping to protect your account from significant losses. If you’re looking for a tool to simplify this process, consider using a position size calculator, which can handle these calculations quickly and accurately . 

What are the most effective position sizing strategies?

When it comes to position sizing strategies, there are a few effective methods that traders often use to manage risk and optimize their trading performance:

  • Percent of Equity: This is a straightforward method where you allocate a fixed percentage of your total account equity to each trade. For instance, if you decide on 5%, you would invest 5% of your account in each trade. This method helps maintain consistent exposure across trades and is particularly useful for normalizing catastrophic stock-specific risks .
  • Risk-Based Position Sizing: This approach involves calculating the risk per share (difference between entry and stop-loss prices) and ensuring that the potential loss on any trade is a fixed percentage of your account. For example, if you risk 1% of a $100,000 account, you would adjust your position size so that a loss would equate to $1,000. This method ensures that your expected loss is consistent across trades .
  • Volatility-Based Position Sizing: Here, you adjust your position size based on the stock’s volatility, often using the Average True Range (ATR) as a measure. The idea is to normalize the impact of volatility on your portfolio by buying fewer shares of more volatile stocks and more shares of less volatile ones .

Each of these methods has its strengths, and the choice depends on your trading style and risk tolerance. It’s often beneficial to backtest these strategies to see which aligns best with your trading objectives . 

What is the formula for risk per trade and how does it impact position size?

The formula for risk per trade is crucial for determining position size and managing risk effectively. Here’s how it works:

  • Risk Per Trade Formula: The risk per trade is calculated by multiplying your account equity by the percentage of your account you’re willing to risk on a single trade. For example, if you have a $10,000 account and decide to risk 1% per trade, your risk per trade would be $100 .
  • Impact on Position Size: Once you know your risk per trade, you can calculate the position size by dividing the risk per trade by the risk per share. The risk per share is the difference between your entry price and your stop-loss price. For instance, if your risk per share is $0.50, and your risk per trade is $100, you can buy 200 shares ($100 / $0.50) .

This approach ensures that your potential loss is consistent across trades, helping to protect your account from significant drawdowns. By standardizing your position size, you maintain a balanced risk profile, which is essential for long-term trading success . 

How does a position size calculator work?

A position size calculator is a handy tool for traders to determine the optimal number of shares or contracts to buy or sell in a trade, ensuring effective risk management. Here’s how it generally works:

  • Select a Position Sizing Model: You start by choosing a model that fits your trading style. Common models include Percent of Equity, Percent Risk, and Percent Volatility .
  • Input Key Parameters: Depending on the model, you’ll need to input various parameters:
    • Percent of Equity: Enter your total account equity and the percentage of equity you want to allocate per trade.
    • Percent Risk: Input your account equity, the percentage of risk per trade, entry price, and stop-loss price to calculate risk per share.
    • Percent Volatility: Provide your account equity, target entry price, and stock volatility (often measured by ATR) .
  • Calculate Position Size: The calculator uses these inputs to compute the number of shares or contracts to trade. For example, in the Percent Risk model, it divides your dollar risk per trade by the risk per share to determine the number of shares .

This tool helps traders maintain consistency and manage risk effectively by standardizing position sizes across trades. It’s particularly useful for beginners who want to ensure they’re not overexposing themselves to risk . 

 

Can position sizing help improve trading consistency and reduce losses?

Absolutely, position sizing is a key factor in improving trading consistency and reducing losses. Here’s how it plays a crucial role:

  • Consistent Risk Management: By using a consistent position sizing strategy, such as risking a fixed percentage of your account on each trade, you ensure that no single trade can significantly impact your overall portfolio. This consistency helps in managing risk effectively and prevents large drawdowns .
  • Psychological Stability: Knowing that your risk is controlled can help maintain emotional stability, reducing the likelihood of making impulsive decisions based on fear or greed. This stability is crucial for sticking to your trading plan over the long term .
  • Long-Term Profitability: Position sizing allows you to take advantage of the law of large numbers. By consistently applying your strategy over many trades, you increase the likelihood of realizing the expected profitability of your trading system .
  • Avoiding Catastrophic Losses: By not over-leveraging on any single trade, you protect your account from catastrophic losses that can occur if a trade goes against you. This is particularly important because you never know in advance which trades will be winners or losers .

Incorporating a disciplined position sizing approach is essential for any trader looking to achieve consistent results and minimize risk.

What is the R factor in the stock market and how is it used?

The R factor, or R-multiple, is a concept used in trading to measure the return on a trade relative to the risk taken. It’s a simple yet powerful tool for evaluating trade performance and managing risk. Here’s how it works:

  • Calculation: The R-multiple is calculated by dividing the return on a trade by the risk taken on that trade. For example, if you enter a trade at $5.00, set a stop loss at $4.50, and exit at $10.00, your R-multiple would be 10. Conversely, if you exit at $4.75, the R-multiple would be -0.5 .
  • Usage: Traders use the R-multiple to assess the effectiveness of their trades and strategies. A positive R-multiple indicates a profitable trade, while a negative one shows a loss. By analyzing the distribution of R-multiples across trades, traders can identify patterns and make informed decisions about risk management and strategy adjustments .
  • Risk Management: Understanding the R-multiple helps traders avoid risking too much on any single trade. For instance, if a trade results in a loss of 5.1 times the intended risk, it highlights the need for careful risk management to prevent significant drawdowns .

Using the R-multiple effectively can lead to greater consistency and confidence in trading, as it provides a clear framework for evaluating risk and reward .

How do you size positions for intraday or swing trading?

Position sizing for intraday or swing trading involves a few key steps to ensure effective risk management and consistency. Here’s a breakdown:

  • Determine Risk Per Trade: Decide on the percentage of your account you’re willing to risk on each trade. For instance, risking 1% of your account per trade is a common approach. This means if you have a $10,000 account, you’d risk $100 per trade .
  • Calculate Risk Per Unit: For intraday or swing trading, this involves setting a stop-loss level based on technical analysis or volatility measures like the Average True Range (ATR). The risk per unit is the difference between your entry price and your stop-loss price .
  • Position Size Formula: Use the formula: Position Size = (Account Equity x Risk Per Trade) / Risk Per Unit. This ensures that each trade has a standardized risk, allowing you to maintain consistency across trades .
  • Volatility Consideration: For swing trading, you might use volatility-based position sizing, where you adjust your position size based on the stock’s volatility. This helps in normalizing the risk across different trades .

By following these steps, you can manage risk effectively and maintain consistency in your trading approach. 

 

What are common mistakes traders make with position sizing?

Common mistakes traders make with position sizing can significantly impact their trading success. Here are a few key ones:

  • Over-Leveraging: Traders often use too much leverage, believing that a good backtest guarantees future success. This can lead to catastrophic losses if the market behaves unexpectedly .
  • Inconsistent Position Sizes: Failing to standardize position sizes across trades can result in unpredictable losses. It’s crucial to ensure that each trade has the same dollar risk to maintain consistency and manage risk effectively .
  • Ignoring Market Conditions: Not adjusting position sizes based on market volatility or changing conditions can lead to increased risk. It’s important to consider factors like volatility when determining position sizes .
  • Neglecting to Monitor Strategy Performance: Traders sometimes blindly follow a strategy without monitoring its performance. If the strategy’s edge diminishes, it can lead to unexpected losses .
  • Failing to Reduce Size During Drawdowns: Continuing to trade with the same position size during a drawdown can exacerbate losses. It’s essential to adjust position sizes to protect your account .

Avoiding these mistakes can help traders maintain consistency, manage risk, and ultimately improve their trading results.

 

author avatar
Adrian Reid Founder and CEO
Adrian is a full-time private trader based in Australia and also the Founder and Trading Coach at Enlightened Stock Trading, which focuses on educating and supporting traders on their journey to profitable systems trading. Following his successful adoption of systematic trading which generated him hundreds of thousands of dollars a year using just 30 minutes a day to manage his system trading workflow, Adrian made the easy decision to leave his professional work in the corporate world in 2012. Adrian trades long/short across US, Australian and international stock markets and the cryptocurrency markets. His trading systems are now fully automated and have consistently outperformed international share markets with dramatically reduced risk over the past 20+ years. Adrian focuses on building portfolios of profitable, stable and robust long term trading systems to beat market returns with high risk adjusted returns. Adrian teaches traders from all over the world how to get profitable, confident and consistent by trading systematically and backtesting their own trading systems. He helps profitable traders grow and smooth returns by implementing a portfolio of trading systems to make money from different markets and market conditions.