Trading Books: Evidence-based Technical Analysis: Applying the Scientific Method and Statistical Inference to Trading Signals

Author: David Aronson
Publisher: Wiley
Year: 2006

Topics Covered:

  • Methodological, Psychological, Philosophical, and Statistical Foundations
  • Case Study: Signal Rules for the S&P 500 Index

Click the image below to buy it now on Amazon:

Trading book review_david aronson_evidence-based technical analysis

Trading Book Review of ‘Evidence-based Technical Analysis: Applying the Scientific Method and Statistical Inference to Trading Signals’ by David Aronson:

This book helps shatter some of the myths and folk law about technical analysis. There are several interesting ideas in the book, however, the key message from me on this is to learn how to backtest your trading ideas and use a system rather than blindly believing that traditional technical analysis will give you an edge – It won’t. If you have other trading books that you can recommend then please leave me a comment below and I will make a review about it!

Frequently Asked Questions about Based Technical Analysis

Is there any evidence that technical analysis works?

Technical analysis can indeed be effective, but its success largely depends on how it’s applied. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Objective Decision-Making: Technical analysis allows traders to make decisions based on objective criteria rather than subjective judgment. This can lead to more consistent trading outcomes .
  • Backtesting: It’s crucial to backtest technical indicators and trading systems to ensure they have a positive edge. This involves testing your rules on historical data to see how they would have performed in the past .
  • Integration into Systems: Combining technical indicators into a complete trading system and backtesting it can significantly increase your chances of success. This approach helps you understand the potential profitability and reliability of your strategy .
  • Indicators and Patterns: Technical analysis uses indicators like moving averages, RSI, and MACD, as well as chart patterns, to identify potential trade opportunities. These tools can help confirm trends and suggest entry and exit points .

While technical analysis can be powerful, it’s important to remember that no single indicator or method guarantees success. Consistent application, backtesting, and integration into a broader trading strategy are key to leveraging technical analysis effectively.

Does technical analysis work in trading?

Technical analysis can be effective in trading, but its success largely depends on how it’s applied. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Objective Decision-Making: Technical analysis allows traders to make decisions based on objective criteria rather than subjective judgment. This can lead to more consistent trading outcomes .
  • Backtesting: It’s crucial to backtest technical indicators and trading systems to ensure they have a positive edge. This involves testing your rules on historical data to see how they would have performed in the past .
  • Integration into Systems: Combining technical indicators into a complete trading system and backtesting it can significantly increase your chances of success. This approach helps you understand the potential profitability and reliability of your strategy .
  • Indicators and Patterns: Technical analysis uses indicators like moving averages, RSI, and MACD, as well as chart patterns, to identify potential trade opportunities. These tools can help confirm trends and suggest entry and exit points .

While technical analysis can be powerful, it’s important to remember that no single indicator or method guarantees success. Consistent application, backtesting, and integration into a broader trading strategy are key to leveraging technical analysis effectively. 

Why do 99% of day traders fail?

Day trading is notoriously challenging, and there are several reasons why a high percentage of day traders fail:

  • Lack of a Proven System: Many traders jump into the market without a well-tested trading system. This leads to inconsistent decision-making and poor results .
  • Emotional Decision-Making: Trading can be emotionally taxing, and without a systematic approach, traders often make impulsive decisions driven by fear or greed, leading to significant losses .
  • Overconfidence and Psychological Traps: Traders often fall into psychological traps like overconfidence, which can lead to taking excessive risks and ignoring their trading plans .
  • Poor Risk Management: Many traders fail to manage their risk properly, which can result in large losses that wipe out their trading accounts. Proper position sizing and avoiding excessive leverage are crucial .
  • Unrealistic Expectations: New traders often have unrealistic expectations about the profits they can achieve, leading to frustration and poor decision-making when those expectations aren’t met .
  • Inconsistency: Without a consistent approach, traders struggle to refine and improve their strategies, leading to ongoing mistakes and losses .

Addressing these challenges requires education, discipline, and a systematic approach to trading.

Do all day traders use technical analysis?

Not all day traders use technical analysis, but it’s a common approach. Many day traders rely on technical analysis because it focuses on price movements and patterns, which can be crucial for making quick trading decisions. However, some traders might incorporate other methods, such as:

  • Fundamental Analysis: Though less common for day trading, some traders might consider news events or earnings reports that could impact short-term price movements.
  • Quantitative Analysis: Some traders use algorithms and quantitative models to make trading decisions based on statistical data.
  • Sentiment Analysis: This involves gauging market sentiment through social media, news, and other sources to predict short-term price movements.

While technical analysis is popular due to its focus on price action and patterns, successful day trading often involves a combination of strategies tailored to the trader’s style and market conditions.

Is there a 100% winning strategy in forex?

There isn’t a 100% winning strategy in forex or any other market, for that matter. The idea of a perfect strategy is a bit of a myth. Markets are inherently unpredictable, and even the best strategies will have losing trades. Here’s why:

  • Market Uncertainty: Markets are influenced by countless factors, many of which are unpredictable. This makes it impossible to create a strategy that wins all the time .
  • Probabilities, Not Certainties: Trading is about probabilities. Successful traders focus on strategies that have a positive expectancy over time, meaning they win more than they lose, or their winners are larger than their losers .
  • Adaptability: A good strategy should be adaptable to different market conditions. No single strategy works all the time, so traders need to be flexible and adjust their approach as needed .
  • Risk Management: Even with a high win rate, poor risk management can lead to significant losses. It’s crucial to manage risk effectively to ensure long-term success .

The key is to find a strategy that fits your personality and objectives, test it thoroughly, and apply it consistently with discipline. 

How to avoid common mistakes in TA?

Avoiding common mistakes in technical analysis (TA) is crucial for improving your trading outcomes. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Avoid Overcomplicating: Using too many indicators can lead to conflicting signals, making it difficult to make clear decisions. Stick to a few that you understand well and that complement each other .
  • Backtest Your Strategies: Ensure your TA strategies are backtested on historical data to confirm their effectiveness. This helps in understanding how they perform under different market conditions .
  • Stay Objective: Emotional decision-making can cloud your judgment. Rely on objective data from your indicators rather than subjective interpretations of chart patterns .
  • Adapt to Market Conditions: Markets change, and so should your strategies. Be ready to adjust your approach based on current market trends and conditions .
  • Focus on Risk Management: Even with a solid TA strategy, poor risk management can lead to significant losses. Always define your risk parameters and stick to them .

By focusing on these areas, you can enhance your technical analysis skills and reduce the likelihood of making costly mistakes.

Do day traders use technical analysis?

Absolutely, many day traders do use technical analysis as a key part of their trading strategy. Technical analysis involves using charts and indicators to identify patterns and trends that can suggest trade ideas. It’s particularly popular among day traders because it focuses on price action and market trends, which are crucial for making quick trading decisions .

However, it’s important to note that while technical analysis is widely used, it’s not the only approach. Some traders might also incorporate elements of fundamental analysis, quantitative analysis, or sentiment analysis to complement their strategies. The key is to find a method that aligns with your trading style and objectives .

If you’re exploring technical analysis, remember that it’s most effective when combined with a systematic approach. This means backtesting your strategies to ensure they have a positive expectancy and applying them consistently to reduce emotional decision-making and improve your trading outcomes .

What is the most successful trading indicator?

There isn’t a single “most successful” trading indicator because the effectiveness of an indicator depends on your trading strategy, the market conditions, and your personal trading style. However, some indicators are widely used and respected for their ability to provide valuable insights:

  • Moving Averages: These help smooth out price action and identify trends by calculating the average price over a specified period. They’re great for spotting trend direction and potential reversal points .
  • Relative Strength Index (RSI): This momentum indicator measures the speed and change of price movements, helping identify overbought or oversold conditions. It’s particularly useful in trend-following systems .
  • Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD): This indicator is used to identify potential trends and trade opportunities by showing the relationship between two moving averages of a security’s price .

The key is to use these indicators as tools to support your trading decisions, not as standalone solutions. It’s crucial to backtest your strategies and ensure they align with your trading objectives and risk tolerance.

How accurate is technical analysis?

Technical analysis (TA) can be a powerful tool for traders, but its accuracy isn’t guaranteed. It’s more about probabilities than certainties. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Historical Data: TA relies on historical price and volume data to identify patterns and trends. While these patterns can suggest potential future movements, they don’t predict them with certainty .
  • Subjectivity: The interpretation of charts and indicators can be subjective. Different traders might see different patterns or signals in the same data, leading to varying conclusions .
  • Market Conditions: The effectiveness of TA can vary depending on market conditions. What works well in a trending market might not be as effective in a range-bound market .
  • Backtesting: To improve the reliability of TA, it’s crucial to backtest your strategies on historical data. This helps you understand how a strategy might perform under different conditions and refine it accordingly .
  • Complementary Approach: TA is often most effective when used in conjunction with other forms of analysis, such as fundamental analysis, to provide a more comprehensive view of the market .

Ultimately, the accuracy of technical analysis depends on how well you understand and apply it, and how disciplined you are in following your trading plan.

author avatar
Adrian Reid Founder and CEO
Adrian is a full-time private trader based in Australia and also the Founder and Trading Coach at Enlightened Stock Trading, which focuses on educating and supporting traders on their journey to profitable systems trading. Following his successful adoption of systematic trading which generated him hundreds of thousands of dollars a year using just 30 minutes a day to manage his system trading workflow, Adrian made the easy decision to leave his professional work in the corporate world in 2012. Adrian trades long/short across US, Australian and international stock markets and the cryptocurrency markets. His trading systems are now fully automated and have consistently outperformed international share markets with dramatically reduced risk over the past 20+ years. Adrian focuses on building portfolios of profitable, stable and robust long term trading systems to beat market returns with high risk adjusted returns. Adrian teaches traders from all over the world how to get profitable, confident and consistent by trading systematically and backtesting their own trading systems. He helps profitable traders grow and smooth returns by implementing a portfolio of trading systems to make money from different markets and market conditions.