How to Properly Interpret Bullish Percent Systematic Trading

The Bullish Percent Index (BPI) is a trading indicator that measures the percentage of stocks exhibiting Point & Figure (P&F) Buy Signals. This valuable tool helps traders assess a market’s internal health, providing insights beyond just market movement and price fluctuations.

A high BPI indicates that most stocks in an index are following bullish patterns, while a low BPI suggests broad bearish market sentiment. Unlike other market analysis tools like RSI or MACD, which can be applied to individual stocks, BPI is best used to evaluate the broader market context at the index level.

For technical analysts and systematic traders, BPI offers an objective, rule-based approach to understanding potential future trends, and potential market reversals. This methodology minimizes emotional decision-making and focuses on quantifiable market psychology.

The BPI is calculated using Point-and-Figure charts, a technical indicator that tracks trends based on price movements rather than time. Stock traders can follow these steps to calculate the percent index indicator:

1. Select the list of symbols within an index or sector, such as the S&P 500, Nasdaq, or Technology Sector.
2. Analyze each stock’s figure chart to determine if it is on a P&F Buy Signal, which occurs when a column of Xs exceeds the previous column of Xs.
3. Use the formula: BPI = (Number of Bullish Stocks ÷ Total Number of Stocks) × 100

For example, if 300 out of 500 stocks in an index generate bullish buy signals, the BPI is 60%, indicating that bullish sentiment dominates.

BPI helps traders assess market participants’ sentiment and potential bullish or bearish track changes. Here’s how traders interpret it:

1. Above 50%: Confirms a bullish market sentiment, favoring long trades. If it falls below 50%, it signals a bearish market.
2. Above 70%: The market is likely overbought, often preceding a correction, while below 30% suggests an oversold market, often preceding a market rally.
3. Bull Confirmed: A signal when the BPI moves from below 30% to a rising column of Xs, indicating potential market reversals.
4. Bear Confirmed: A bearish alert occurs when the BPI moves from above 70% to a falling column of Os, signaling a downward trend.

These signals can help traders align their strategies with market conditions, reducing unnecessary market exposure.

Many investors react emotionally, often buying at market peaks and selling at extended bear markets. Using BPI within a rules-based investment strategy ensures reliance on informed trading strategies rather than gut feelings.

Key BPI Trading Strategies

1. Long Trades: Enter when BPI crosses above 50% and look for shorting opportunities when BPI drops below 50%.
2. Recovery Confirmation: Buying when BPI moves from below 30% to above 30% confirms an uptrend.
3. Testing Historical Data: Analyzing dozens of indices ensures optimal entry and exit strategies.

Traders can avoid emotional reactions by implementing elite investment advisors’ strategies with clear, rules-based investment objectives.

While BPI is potentially a useful market indicator, traders should acknowledge its limitations. For a start, very few trading software packages can plot point and figure charts, and even fewer can backtest trading strategies that use P&F charts. This makes the use of the Bullish Percent Index cumbersome because calculations may have to be done manually.

If you can overcome the first challenge, the second major issue is that BPI reacts slowly to rapid market changes since it is based on cumulative P&F signals, making it more suited for medium-to-long-term trading systems rather than short-term scalping or trading.

Markets can remain overbought or oversold longer than expected, leading to false signals. Confirmation from other technical analysis tools like moving averages and RSI helps avoid premature trading strategies.

To make the most of BPI, traders should integrate it with technical analysis tools:

1. Combine BPI with Moving Averages: Ensures alignment with broader market trends.
2. Define Entry and Exit Rules: Enter long trades when BPI is above 50% for three days and exit when it drops below 50%.
3. Backtest Strategies: Optimize box size and 3-box reversal patterns for different markets (if your trading software allows you to backtest P&F strategies. Unfortunately Amibroker does not have this capability)

The Bullish Percent Index is most effective when combined with other market analysis tools like Moving Averages, RSI, and MACD.

Moving Averages and BPI

• If BPI rises above 50% while the market index trades above the 50-day and 200-day moving averages, it confirms an uptrend.
• If BPI drops below 50% while the market index is below these averages, it signals a bear market.

RSI and BPI

• RSI adds another layer by identifying overbought or oversold conditions.
• If the BPI is above 70% but the RSI remains below 70, the trend may continue.
• If the BPI is below 30% and the RSI is also below 30, it strengthens the case for a reversal.

MACD and BPI

• A bullish point-and-figure chart pattern is stronger when MACD is positive with a bullish crossover.
• A bearish market sentiment is confirmed when MACD is negative despite a rising BPI.

The difficulty backtesting this potentially interesting trading indicator is a showstopper for me. I want trading tools that are easy to code and backtest so I can build confidence they work and deploy them quickly without ruining my lifestyle. I refuse to use trading strategies that are not 100% objective and backtest-able because I have found that the results are too erratic, they frequently result in losses and my emotions typically get in the way of good decisions.

If you’re looking to master systematic trading strategies, apply now to The Trader Success System. This program teaches traders how to build rules-based systems that maximize consistency and reduce emotional biases.